The wrestlers are strong, articulate, disciplined winners who’ve travelled all over the world and are public figures in their own right. Yet even they had to knock on the Supreme Court’s doors for the most basic demand of getting the police to do their job and lodge an FIR (first information report).
On April 21, seven women wrestlers went to Delhi’s Connaught Place police to file a complaint against Brij Bhushan Sharan Singh, a six-time BJP MP who heads the Wrestling Federation of India (what skill politicians bring to sporting bodies is a question for another day). The police shooed them away and refused to file an FIR.
Undaunted, the women approached the Supreme Court. On Wednesday, solicitor general Tushar Mehta told the top court that the police “felt” some preliminary enquiry was needed before registering an FIR. Chief Justice DY Chandrachud said the allegations were “serious” and listed the next hearing for Friday.
On Friday, when the hearing began after lunch, the Delhi police quickly told the court it would register an FIR after all. Senior advocate Kapil Sibal, representing the women, also asked the court to issue directions to provide security to the wrestlers.
Wrestlers Vinesh Phogat addresses the media during a protest against Wrestling Federation of India (WFI) chief Brij Bhushan Singh, (Source: ANI)
Singh is accused of abusing his position as federation head and sexually molesting several women wrestlers including one who was 16, legally a minor, at the time.
In the public eye
The issue first flared up in January when the wrestlers came to Delhi’s Jantar Mantar in what Sportstar calls the “biggest protest by Indian athletes against sports administrators in recent memory”.
Two-time world medallist Vinesh Phogat said she personally knew of “at least 10 to 20 girls” who had been sexually harassed at wrestling camp. Sources say the number is likely to be significantly higher.
Given the media spotlight, the sports ministry set up an oversight committee headed by boxer MC Mary Kom. Reassured of action, the protestors went home.
Kom was given four weeks to prepare her report, asked for an extension of two additional weeks and says she has submitted the report to the ministry.
Four months later, the wrestlers were back. “This is not wrestling’s fight alone. I request all the athletes of the country, all the players, to come and join us,” Bajrang Punia said.
The bahubali muscle
In the badlands of Uttar Pradesh, Brij Bhushan Sharan Singh is what is known as a “bahubali” or strong man. His election affidavit lists four cases ending against him, including dacoity and attempt to murder.
The refusal to lodge an FIR against him is precisely “because he is a member of Parliament of the ruling party,” Kapil Sibal told me on the phone.
At the time of writing, only Kapil Dev, Abhinav Bindra, Neeraj Chopra and Sania Mirza had come out in support for the wrestlers.
Most dispiriting was the statement by Indian Olympic Association president PT Usha who criticised the wrestlers of “indiscipline” and “tarnishing the image of the country”. It summarised a common and misogynist attitude to women who find the courage to speak up: Good women don’t complain
Wrestling Federation of India (WFI) chief Brij Bhushan Singh (Source: PTI)
But Singh is not the only politician to be accused of sexual assault.
In January this year, a junior athletics coach held a press conference where she accused Haryana sports minister Sandeep Singh of sexual harassment. After Chandigarh police booked Singh for stalking, sexual harassment, criminal force, illegal confinement and criminal intimidation, Singh quit as sports minister on “moral grounds”. But he continues to be a minister in the BJP government, retaining his second portfolio as minister for printing and stationery.
It’s easy to see which way the wind blows. Haryana chief minister said mere allegations don’t make a person guilty; the Speaker of the assembly made caustic remarks on how such allegations are often followed by a “compromise” and even the chairperson of the state women’s commission said the charges appear to be “unbelievable”, write Jagmati Sangwan and Indu Agnihotri in this opinion piece.
In court, Singh’s lawyer has asked for time to file a reply to a Special Investigation Team’s request for a lie detector test.
Then, on Tuesday April 25, the woman coach was returning home after filling fuel in her two-wheeler when, she says, a black SUV tried to run her over. “I was saved as I stepped aside in the nick of time,” she told Hindustan Times.
And, of course, there is Rakesh Singh Senger, the MLA who was finally expelled from the BJP.
It took a desperate threat by a 19-year-old woman to immolate herself in front of Uttar Pradesh chief minister Yogi Adityanath’s house before the police would even arrest Senger.
In 2019, a Delhi court, under the supervision of the Supreme Court, found Senger guilty of kidnapping and raping the 19-year-old in 2017. The judgment also criticised the CBI for the delay in filing a charge-sheet in the case and prolonging the trial. And it referred to the vendetta against the woman and her family members.
From Bilkis to Hathras, blatant impunity
Enough has been written about how 11 men convicted of such heinous crimes as gang-rape and mass murder during the 2002 Gujarat riots were granted early release from jail after being sentenced to life imprisonment.
The governments are clearly dragging their feet – one of the judges in the two judge bench, KM Joseph retires in June – as it said it was “considering” filing a review petition against the order to produce the file.
“Every time there is a hearing, one accused will come to this court and seek adjournment. Four weeks later, another accused will do the same and this will go on till December. We are aware of this strategy as well,” said Justice BV Nagarathna, the other judge on the bench.
In fact, said senior advocate Vrinda Grover: “Judicial delay is an adjunct to impunity.”
Sometimes the hurdle isn’t an individual politician but the state.
Perhaps no case has highlighted the sheer brazen-ness of state power than the Hathras case where a 19-year-old Dalit woman was cremated in the middle of the night by the police. Her family was not allowed to even see her for a final farewell.
In March this year, a UP court acquitted three of the four men accused of raping and murdering the woman.
In Andhra Pradesh, it took 15 years after 11 tribal women were allegedly gang-raped at gunpoint by an anti-Naxal special police team at Vakapalli, for a special court to deliver judgment: Not guilty. The verdict, however, was a result of “shoddy investigation” the judge said and ruled that the rape survivors were entitled to compensation.
Two of the 11 women had already died during the trial.
News you may have missed
Marriage equality update
Members of United Hindu Front stage a protest against same-sex marriage (Source: PTI)
Lawyers for the 52 petitioners who are asking for the same right to marry as any other citizen of India, have wrapped up their arguments before a five-judge Supreme Court bench. The court is now hearing from Solicitor General Tushar Mehta on why this right should not be granted. On the sixth day of arguments , the bench acknowledged that rewriting the Special Marriage Act to make it gender neutral would be a complex task involving several laws. It conceded that legislative change is the job of Parliament but urged the state to recognise non-heterosexual unions with some institutional label. “There is a corresponding duty on the state to at least recognise that all the incidents of social cohabitation must find recognition in the law,” the bench observed.
Their only child, a 23-year-old son was killed in a road accident. The mother, now 45, has had a hysterectomy. There is a long line in the adoption queue. And the father is 57, two years older than the cut off age stipulated in the surrogacy law.
In response to the desperate plea by a couple seeking to have a child through surrogacy, the Karnataka high court pointed to several anomalies. For instance, the court said, altruistic surrogacy should logically be extended to women who are not necessarily blood relatives. The only thing that counts, the court said, was the genetic, physical and financial status of the couple seeking surrogacy.
And the good news…
You know that stereotype about girls and maths? It’s this sexist stereotype that has resulted in girls performing more poorly than boys, finds a new report. Looking at data from 100 countries, the report by Unicef finds that boys have higher odds of learning maths skills than girls because negative gender norms held by parents, teacher and peers are contributing to this disparity, undermining girls’ confidence and setting them up for failure.
Representational Image (Source: Unsplash)
Last year, women reported higher levels of burnout. But this year, Deloitte’s Women@Work global outlook for 2023, found not just lower levels of burnout but more women reporting positive experiences with hybrid work.
Challenges remain. The number of women who feel unable to switch off from work has increased while the number of women who are comfortable talking about mental health concerns with employers has decreased. Stigma around women’s health also included challenges related to menstruation and menopause.
Read the report here.
AROUND THE WORLD
Balesh Dhankar (Source: Facebook)
In Sydney, Balesh Dhankhar, a Haryana-born NRI, has been described as the “worst rapist” in the city’s history, by a court that convicted him for as many as 39 sexual offences.
Dhankhar’s cross examination in court revealed stomach-churning details of how he lured his victims with fake job ads, used drugs to render them unconscious before raping them, filming them, and even maintaining meticulous files on each. The Sydney Morning Herald says Dhankhar who headed the Overseas Friends of the BJP and had uploaded pictures of himself with Prime Minister Narendra Modi tried to conceal his identity through the trial using suppression orders, sprinting away from cameras outside court and even removing photographs from social media. He will be sentenced later in the year.
In Vatican City, women will be allowed to participate and vote for the first time at an upcoming meeting in October of Catholic bishops. The meeting, or synod, will also see the participation of lay people for the first time, a change that has the approval and sanction of Pope Francis, reports CNN.
In Thailand, a conservative political party has backed the legalisation of sex toys as it “seeks to revive its appeal” before next month’s general elections, reports The Guardian. Ratchada Thanadirek of the Democrat party said sex toys were being smuggled into the country anyway, leading to a potential loss of revenue by way of taxes. The penalty for selling sex toys in the country can be as high as a three-year prison term and a fine of the rough equivalent of Rs 1.42 lakh.
A good week for the abortion pill with the US Supreme Court preserving women’s access to mifepristone, the drug used in the most common method of abortion. The top court has granted emergency requests from the Joe Biden administration and Danco Labs that makes the drug until an appeal against a lower court order that effectively banned the drug. In Japan, meanwhile, the health ministry has approved the country’s first abortion pill, decades after other countries made abortion medication widely available.