We are all losers here
The poor quality of social discourse is blurring the lines between public and private, Namita Bhandare writes. What would Twitter have made of Jawaharlal Nehru’s relationship with Edwina Mountbatten or Gandhiji’s sleeping arrangement with his nieces? And how would judgement have been pronounced in 140 characters on Ram Manohar Lohia’s live-in relationship with professor Rama Mitra? For that matter, when did the lines between public and private blur? And when did a personal matter between two people, regardless of the office they hold, become the subject of legitimate discourse? Delhi’s favourite sport of cheering while reputations crumble seems to have…
Hitting the RTE note
As the final bell goes off in my daughter’s school, a ripple of anticipation runs through a group of children waiting at the gate. Tiny hands stretch through eager to touch those on the other side. HT Image As the final bell goes off in my daughter’s school, a ripple of anticipation runs through a group of children waiting at the gate. Tiny hands stretch through eager to touch those on the other side. For an instant, a single handshake seems to bridge an insurmountable distance, the meeting of the children of the two Indias: one that is elite, entitled…
We say ‘bring it on’
Satyamev Jayate endorses the opening up of traditional sources of information. Namita Bhandare writes. HT Image That Satyamev Jayate, Aamir Khan’s reality show, is rocking TV panel discussions and newspaper headlines a week after its debut, says something about its impact. A ‘movement for social change’, an ‘exquisite piece of journalism’ and ‘television history’ are some of the more measured epithets. Yes, the cynics are weighing in too: do you really need a celebrity to expose the gritty reality of fem-ale foeticide? Hasn’t the press been writing/talking about it for years? Isn’t this a commercial venture for a Bollywood actor?…
To live happily ever after
In the din of the unseemly skirmish between the army chief and the defence minister, a little Bill that could have big implications on marriage slipped by relatively unnoticed and unsung. HT Image In the din of the unseemly skirmish between the army chief and the defence minister, a little Bill that could have big implications on marriage slipped by relatively unnoticed and unsung. The Cabinet this past week approved the Marriage Amendments Bill (2010). If passed by Parliament, it has the potential to become a new deal for thousands of women trapped in abusive marriages. The Bill marks three…
Norway puzzle: 10 questions in custody row
The case of Norwegian authorities taking away two Indian children for “safe custody” has had several twists and turns. The media may have gone overboard and the government may have spoken on the matter too soon. But were the Norwegians justified in taking away the children? Namita Bhandare asks in 10 questions. A-file-photo-of-Sagarika-Bhattacharya-and-her-child If you’ve been following the twists and turns in the hairpin saga known as the Norway kids custody case, then you’re probably as dizzy I am. It’s been quite a ride. Yes, Anurup Bhattacharya concealed facts about his troubled marriage. Yes, revelations about his wife’s so-called psychological…
Norwegian nightmare: State-sponsored child protection racket
Has there been anything more outrageous, cruel and insensitive than the Norway kids case? Dark as a Scandinavian winter, this unbelievable story shows no sign of ending soon. Namita Bhandare writes. Norway-s-child-protection-rights-come-under-scanner Has there been anything more outrageous, cruel and insensitive than the Norway kids case? Dark as a Scandinavian winter, this unbelievable story shows no sign of ending soon. On February 15, three weeks after the ministry of external affairs reached an understanding with the Norwegian government for custody of the minor Indian children, currently in separate foster homes, to be handed over to their paternal uncle, the ministry…
New energy eludes politics
It is up to Akhilesh Yadav to be the change that the voters have sought. Namita Bhandare writes. The burden of hope lies heavy on Akhilesh Yadav. Uttar Pradesh’s 38-year-old chief minister brings expectation that he will break from the past and usher in new beginnings, beginnings that include development not caste, roads not monuments, jobs not patronage. Hope is a tough horse to ride and it has toppled many reputations in the past. Those who voted Akhilesh for the first time were not born when an exuberant Rajiv Gandhi swore to stamp out ‘powerbrokers’ in his Mumbai Congress centenary…
It’s just an exam, silly!
The purpose of education goes beyond a test that asks predictable questions. Namita Bhandare writes. I see them huddled outside the school gates. Some are engaged in chit chat, others stare at unread newspapers as they wait for their children to emerge from the examination centre. They are this year’s batch of anxious parents, prisoners along with their children in the annual rite of board examinations. My daughter has another year to go. Yet, I’m already laying out commandments: coaching classes in the summer, no missing school and just forget about holidays. But I’m no tiger mother. My children have…
A blot on our conscience
Human trafficking continues to thrive because of our misplaced priorities, writes Namita Bhandare. For close to a month, a two-year-old baby girl called Falak has gripped the imagination of a nation. Brought in with a fractured skull, bite marks and bruises, she has undergone four surgeries, and is on and off the ventilator. Who knows how her story will end? Will she have permanent brain damage? Will she end up institutionalised? Will she live? For now, it’s just a struggle to make it through another day. Falak was brought to the All India Institute of Medical Sciences by a 14-year-old…
Question nothing
Symbiosis College should not have ‘postponed’ the screening of Jashn-e-Azadi. Namita Bhandare writes. HT Image Days after Salman Rushdie cancelled his visit to the Jaipur Literature Festival, the Symbiosis College of Art and Commerce in Pune, acting on a prompt by the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP), the students’ wing of the BJP, postponed indefinitely a seminar on Kashmir that included a screening of Sanjay Kak’s film Jashn-e-Azadi. Elsewhere, in Kolkata, protesting Muslims succeeded in cancelling Taslima Nasreen’s book launch, an event that her publishers held eventually at their own stall at the book fair. Hooliganism’s multiplying effect has been…
It’s a two-way street
If I am to have the freedom to offend, then you must equally have the freedom to rebut – either on a similar platform or in a court of law. Namita Bhandare writes. HT Image Three parables from modern India. A man writes a book that offends some people enough to ban it and, for good measure, demand his head. Salman Rushdie goes underground, in time the fatwa is forgotten, he emerges from hiding and continues writing and travelling. Then, a curious thing happens. He is invited, again, to attend the Jaipur Literature Festival. His name appears on the programme,…
Don’t skirt the real issue
There must be zero tolerance for any attempt to justify crimes against women by blaming the victim herself. Namita Bhandare writes. HT Image So what was the 13-year-old girl from Lakhimpur wearing when she was raped and murdered in August last year? How provocatively dressed was the 77-year-old woman raped and beaten up in March in Delhi? And surely the two-year-old child who was raped by a 60-year-old man near Ludhiana in November must have had an unseemly display of diaper. I have to ask because everyone from Andhra Pradesh DGP Dinesh Reddy to Bangalore University’s head of the committee…